Resistors and Springs

question physics short

Question

What is the effective resistance of two resistors in series?
What is the effective spring constant of two springs in series?
Why are these different?


Hints

Think about what quantities are conserved in series.
Write down the equations that involve resistance and the spring constant.


Answer

Take two resistors in series, $A$ and $B$. For this circuit, using Kirchhoff's Laws:

  • the current through both resistors is equal
  • the voltages of the resistors are added

Let $I$ be the current through the whole circuit. In series, the voltages are added. Using $V = IR$,
$$ V_\text{total} = V_A + V_B = IR_A + IR_B = I(R_A + R_B) = IR_\text{total} $$ Therefore the total resistance is the sum of the two resistors.

Take two springs in series, $1$ and $2$. For this combination:

  • the force acting on each spring is equal (can be checked by resolving forces in equilibrium)
  • the extension of the springs are added (if each spring extends by 1 cm, the combination will extend by 2 cm)

Using $F=kx$, which can be rearranged to $x=F/k$ you can see that the quantity that is equal, $F$, divided by the spring constant; compare this to $V=IR$, where $I$ is conserved but is multiplied by the resistance. Using a similar method, $$ x_\text{total} = x_1 + x_2 = \frac{F}{k_1} + \frac{F}{k_2} = F(\frac{1}{k_1} + \frac{1}{k_2}) = F(\frac{1}{k_\text{total} }) $$ Therefore the reciprocal of the total spring constant is equal to the sum of the reciprocals of the two spring constants.